Readers come away with a better understanding of not only what has occurred in vietnam in the past 50 years, but why it happened. The cost in north vietnamese casualties was tremendous but the gambit produced a pivotal media disaster for the white house and the presidency of lyndon johnson. Senior general vo nguyen giap was, and is, the only pavn figure known at all well outside of vietnam, the only pavn general mentioned in most counts of the vietnam war, and the only vietnamese communist military leader about whom a full length biography has been written. Vietnam war a memoir bio of general vo nguyen giap. At the time he wrote these reflections on the war with the u. The general who defeated america in vietnam by james. How would you compare van tien dung with vo nguyen giap in terms of military talent. General giaps memoirs armchair general and historynet.
In washington, flags were ordered to fly at halfmast for the soldier henry kissinger once credited as the man who singlehandedly got the u. North vietnamese president ho chi minh and the south vietnamese. General vo nguyen giap was the north vietnamese mastermind who defeated the french and american superpowers over 30 years in what was previously an unthinkable possibility that countries with so so much more military and economic power. Did vietnamese general vo nguyen giaps memoirs pin u. The genius of vietnams general vo nguyen giap warriors. Vo nguyen giap, the vietnamese communist commander, the peer of grant, lee, rommel. General vo nguyen giap in military uniform, waving. Former us defence secretary robert mcnamara and general vo nguyen giap, vietnams. My reporting and subsequent research for a book brought me into contact with. Its gripping, engaging, provides historical context, contains essential quotes, and shows giap to be the logistical, tactical, and strategic genius he was as a general leading north vietnam to defeat the japanese, the french, the us, the south vietnamese, the cambodians, and the chinese. Interviews with a top north vietnam army general and two. General vo nguyen giap was the commander in chief of the communist. The following quote is from his memoirs currently found in the vietnam war memorial in hanoi. The peoples army of vietnam of the north and the south vietnam.
By this time, giap was a north vietnamese army general known for defeating u. I found his history to be interesting, especially his education and the foundation of the vietnamese army during the revolution against the french after world war ii. In the wall street journal, john mccain writes that to defeat any adversary, the late north vietnamese gen. Oct 04, 20 collected via email, november 2007 giaps memoirs gen. He has written books on the vietnam war and the cold war and contributed the. Ho ordered him to yenan, in north china, where the chinese communists. Click download or read online button to get general vo nguyen giap book now. General vo nguyen giap obituary vietnam the guardian. Robert mcnamara and the ghosts of vietnam the new york times.
Vo nguyen giap was an army general in the vietnam peoples army and. Englishnat two former warmakers in vietnam have met for the first time 20 years after the end of hostilities. This articles name order is correct according to vietnamese names. Vo nguyen giap masterminded battle of dien bien phu, which led to france leaving indochina, and commanded north s forces in vietnam war published. Vo nguyen giap, southeast asias most successful communist general, minister of defense and commander in chief of north vietnam s army, shares with premier khrushchev a conviction that the future holds many just wars of national liberation. General vo nguyen giap, commander of the north vietnamese army, wrote in his memoirs that his army was on the brink of collapse, but the u.
Reflections of general vo nguyen giap 24hourcampfire. Vo nguyen giap, the vietnamese general who masterminded victories against france and the us, has died aged 102. Former us defence secretary robert mcnamara and general vo nguyen giap, vietnam. There is no other account of north vietnamese general vo nguyen giaps life and his ability to build a victorious peasant war machine as indepth and honest as this work.
He later commanded the vietnam peoples army during the vietnam war. General giap now holds the positions of vicepremier, minister of defeiise and ile head to lim, aiczti. General giap has published his memoirs and confirmed what most americans knew. General vo nguyen giap obituary world news the guardian. General vo nguyen giap top left, smiling with ho chi minh second right during a military campaign in vietnam in 1950. Another important historical site is the headquarters of general vo nguyen giap in the village of phang muong phang. A critical edition of a theoretical summary, a cult book written by one of the greatest strategists of all times, famous under the name of the red napoleon, i. Jul 31, 2015 vietnamese general vo nguyen giap, the brilliant and ruthless commander who led a guerilla army to victory over first the french and then the americans, died on friday. Tin further advised that general vo nguyen giap commanding general of the north vietnam army had advised him the 1968 tet offensive had been a defeat. Korean and vietnam veterans of the rio grande valley. Media caption paul adams looks back at vo nguyen giap s life.
Giap commanded vietnamese forces that defeated the french during the first indochina war and was the minister of defense during the u. Vo nguyen giap permitted immense casualties and the near total destruction of his country. Vietnam war a memoir history of vietnam tet offensive. Curt cardwell has raised the question of the origin of the claim, supposedly by general giap, that the antiwar protesters contributed to the success of the north vietnamese in the war. He was often querulous and rudely didactic, traits that come across in his many books on warfare. Oct 04, 20 vo nguyen giap masterminded battle of dien bien phu, which led to france leaving indochina, and commanded north s forces in vietnam war peter beaumont fri 4 oct 20 11. As he laughingly told me, i was a selftaught general. Davidsons vietnam at war this article was originally published in the october 2005 issue. Jul 21, 2015 englishnat two former warmakers in vietnam have met for the first time 20 years after the end of hostilities. Vo nguyen giap, born 1912, an xa, vietnam died october 4, 20, hanoi, vietnamese military and political leader whose perfection of guerrilla as well as conventional strategy and tactics led to the viet minh victory over the french and to the end of french colonialism in southeast asia and later to the north vietnamese victory over south vietnam and the united states. General vo nguyen giap, north vietnamese military leader jay mallin. General vo nguyen giap the vietnamese napoleon download.
His native village of an xa consisted primarily of straw and bamboo huts, alongside a. Vo nguyen giap, the first fourstar general and the former commanderinchief of the vietnam army, died on oct 4 in hanoi, more than a month after he celebrated his 103rd birthday. The vietnam war was not lost in vietnam it was lost at. Continuing the topic of vietnam war leaders, lets now take a look at major military and political figures of north and south vietnam during the war. Fury was dispatched on a mission to assassinate giap with the aid of u. Just before the american ground war in vietnam began in march 1965 with the landing of a brigade of us marines at danang, general vo nguyen giap, who had been commander in chief of communist armed.
Several leading congressional representatives, led by minority. Vo nguyen giap, right, reads the first military order to the vietnam liberation propaganda army in cao bang province. The disparity between general giap and the othersthe lone figure standing. If youre interested in really finding out how general giap masterminded the military victory in vietnam, this book isnt going to answer the question. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Musthave books for the library of the learned warrior.
Robert mcnamara meets general vo nguyen giap youtube. Giap was the deputy prime minister of vietnam from 1955 to 1991. When the japanese surrendered to the allies after the dropping of atom bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki in august 1945, the vietminh was in a good position to take over the control of the country and vo nguyen giap served under ho chi minh in the. Vo nguyen giap august 25, 1911october 4, 20 was a vietnamese general who led the viet minh during the first indochina war.
The unification of north and south vietnam occurred in 1976. Raised in southern vietnam, he began his military career in the late 1930s fighting against the. General vo nguyen giap download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Vo nguyen giap, the relentless and charismatic north vietnamese general whose campaigns drove both france and the united states out of vietnam, died on friday in hanoi. This place was the headquarters of vietnamese troops and general vo nguyen giap. Vo nguyen giap, born 1912, an xa, vietnam died october 4, 20, hanoi, vietnamese military and political leader whose perfection of guerrilla as well as conventional strategy and tactics led to the viet minh victory over the french and to the end of french colonialism in southeast asia and later to the north vietnamese victory over south vietnam. Van tien dung mar 28th 2002 ap an american historian, eugene grayson, who served in vietnam as a colonel, reckoned that van tien dung was one of the grea. Vo nguyen giap was an army general in the vietnam peoples army and a. Aug 07, 2012 general vo nguyen giap was the north vietnamese mastermind who defeated the french and american superpowers over 30 years in what was previously an unthinkable possibility that countries with so so much more military and economic power could lose to an underdeveloped third world country. Vo nguyne giap was a general for the peoples army of vietnam and was in a leadership position in the tet offensive, the easter offensive, and the ho chi minh campaign. Top ranking general vo nguyen giap during his lifetime and military career, general vo nguyen giap, who is universally considered one of the great men of history and whose death has triggered overwhelming grief and mourning all over the country in the past few days, leaves behind a number of immortal utterances. In early 1968, however, the north vietnamese military commander general vo nguyen giap chose january 31 as the occasion for a coordinated offensive of surprise attacks aimed at breaking the. What we still dont understand is why you americans stopped the bombing of hanoi. Vo nguyen giap, the commander in chief of the north vietnamese army.
General vo nguyen giap, north vietnamese military leader. General vo nguyen giap was the north vietnamese mastermind who defeated the french and american. The general who defeated america in vietnam by james a. Vo nguyen giap, the relentless and charismatic north vietnamese general whose campaigns drove both france and the united states out of. General giap and the myth of american invincibility. General vo nguyen giap was the commander in chief of the communist armed forces during two of his countrys most difficult conflicts. The disparity between general giap and the othersthe lone figure standing in the forefront of a legion of shadowy. It turned the tide of the war and sealed the general s fame as the dominant military genius of the 20th centurys second half. In a rare interview, he recalls his part in defying the might of. How i won the vietnam war april 17, 2016 february 14, 2018 quintus curtius politics, thought guerrilla tactics, vietnam war, vo nguyen giap vo nguyen giap 191120 was the architect of the vietnamese victory in the second indochina war called in the united states the vietnam war, which took place. Vo nguyen giap, the vietnamese communist commander, the peer of grant, lee, rommel and macarthur in the pantheon of military leaders. He defeated the french troops in 1954 in dien bien phu town. Something all of you should think about is what general vo nguyen giap, the commander in chief of the north vietnamese army had to say about john kerry in his 1985 memoir how we won the war.
Clifford geertz, wrote a seminal book in the anthropological community on the. According to vietnamese custom, this person should properly be referred to by the given name giap. His native village of an xa consisted primarily of straw and bamboo huts, alongside a few tileroofed buildings. General giap was a brilliant, highly respected leader of the north vietnam military. Giap was a very famous and knowledgeable general in the north vietnamese army. Vo nguyen giapis one of the worlds best strategists who revolutionized the art of war and the military science. North vietnam tried using force, causing the vietnam war in 1955. General vo nguyen giaps immortal sayings tuoi tre news. Vietnamese president truong tan sang, left, communist party chiefs and soldiers carry the coffin of general vo nguyen giap to an artillery cart at the national funeral house in hanoi. Tran van tra, vietnamese general born 1918 quang ngai province, vietnam, 1918died april 20, 1996, ho chi minh city, vietnam, proved to be an able commander in the vietnam war by leading communist raids on saigon both during the tet offensive of 1968 and during the citys capture in 1975. By examining four of giap s significant campaigns and his role in influencing north vietnamese strategy during the first and second indochina wars, this paper will attempt to determine if giap is truly one of historys greatest military geniuses. For more than 30 years, general giap was the key organizer of the vietnamese armed forces and its main strategic thinker. Collected via email, november 2007 giap s memoirs gen.
Vo nguyen giap has been called one of the greatest military strategists of the 20th century. Oct 05, 20 vo nguyen giap, the relentless and charismatic north vietnamese general whose campaigns drove both france and the united states out of vietnam, died on friday in hanoi. Interesting subject, how north vietnam won the conflict. The general headquarters in the spring of brilliant victory the gioi publishers, hanoi, 2002, has been translated into english and provides a ready. From 1969 to the end of the war, over 20,000 american soldiers lost their lives in a war. General giap has published his memoirs and confirmed. Oct 04, 20 vo nguyen giap, the vietnamese military commander and national folk hero who organized the army that defeated the french and then the americans in 30 years of southeast asian warfare, is dead. Hanoi, vietnam former vietnamese general and perennial democratic presidential candidate vo nguyen giap died this morning at his home in hanoi. This volume stresses the climate of asia, africa, and latin american, torn today. Vo nguyen giap, born 1912, an xa, vietnamdied october 4, 20, hanoi, vietnamese military and political leader whose perfection of guerrilla as well as conventional strategy and tactics led to the viet minh victory over the french and to the end of french colonialism in southeast asia and later to the north vietnamese victory over south.
Ebook general giap politician and strategist as pdf. Oct 04, 20 vo nguyen giap, the vietnamese general who planned the ho chi minh trail and defeated the french at dien bien phu, turns 95 today. Dan just wants everybody to understand that dan has no intention whatsoever to vilify vietnam or vilify vo nguyen giap, he said in the video clip, speaking in. The death of wartime general vo nguyen giap has triggered public mourning in vietnam as 150,000 people lined up to pay respects to the socalled red napoleon. Vo nguyen giap, the military commander of north vietnam during the war, in. Vietnams top military strategist tells the secrets of their vict. Vo nguyen giap was born in quang binh province, central annam. Vo nguyen giap, southeast asias most successful communist general, minister of defense and commander in chief of north vietnams army, shares with premier khrushchev a conviction that the future holds many just wars of national liberation. Vo nguyen giap, a man credited with major victories against the french and the american military, has died, according to local media reports. How would you compare van tien dung with vo nguyen giap in. The general repeats his words, phrases even sentences over and over. Fourstar general vo nguyen giap led vietnam s armies from their inception, in the 1940s, up to the moment of their triumphant entrance into saigon in 1975 possessing one of the finest military minds of this century, his strategy for vanquishing superior opponents was not to simply outmaneuver them in the field but to undermine their resolve by inflicting demoralizing.
The north vietnamese armys most senior officer, general vo nguyen giap, led. Vietnam holds state funeral for general vo nguyen giap. Afpgetty images giap was an unusual figure in the anonymous. Ebook general giap politician and strategist as pdf download. Jul 11, 2017 just before the american ground war in vietnam began in march 1965 with the landing of a brigade of us marines at danang, general vo nguyen giap, who had been commander in chief of communist armed. In early 1968, however, the north vietnamese military commander general vo nguyen giap chose january 31 as the occasion for a coordinated offensive. Unfortunately for fury, giap s men discovered him and castle and imprisoned them. This is a biography of general vo nguyen giap, the founder and general of the north vietnamese army. General giaps funeral salutes vietnam hero daily mail online.
1043 1385 234 962 1276 99 1631 752 332 196 222 1485 1540 51 1304 1565 1332 469 1154 1354 192 1451 1483 1553 853 1511 987 306 824 1335 131 752 742 355 1448 69 1110 709 140 12 79 655